Why didn't Snape turn Harry in?
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Tue Oct 10 18:01:23 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 159352
> "Julie:
> That is exactly my problem with the theory that Snape was hiding
the
> book, from Dumbledore or anyone. Who hides a book in plain sight,
> in a cupboard where anyone can get to it? "
>
> BAW wrote:
> I presume that you are familiar with the stories of Edgar Allen
Poe?
>
>
> Julie again:
> Some, and I was being a bit facetious there. Let's just say Snape
isn't
> going to hide a book in plain sight. Not his MO. If that book
contained
> anything he wanted to keep from Dumbledore or anyone else, I'm sure
> he would have tucked it away safely somewhere, or destroyed it, not
> left it in an unlocked classroom cabinet.
Alla:
What if this is exactly his MO? What if we presume that it is not?
What is the better way for the supposedly turned DE to hide but in
the plain sight of unconditional trust of Albus Dumbledore?
What if Snape hiding the book in the plain sight foreshadows him
hiding his true nature in the plain sight?
Not saying that this is true necessarily, but do wonder where do you
get that Snape cannot hide the book in the plain sight?
JMO,
Alla
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive