[SPAM] RE: [HPforGrownups] Re: Do you all think that Sirius B lack will return back ?

[James Sharman]

No: HPFGUIDX 159454

Jen Wrote:
Nope, Sirius is gone for good. I'm still clinging to the hope that
Dumbledore is not dead. 

Sherry now:

I don't really expect JKR to bring back Sirius. Having said that however,
if she brought back anyone, I'd want it to be Sirius, so Harry has that
person in his life. Also, he's the one character who has died, in the time
frame of Harry's story, not in the past, whose body has never been seen.
I'm talking about major characters or someone affecting Harry's life.
Sirius was a major character to Harry, but his little trip behind the veil
left Harry and us no body. It's kind of suspicious to me. I can live with
Dumbledore being dead. He was an old man after all. 

James writes:

Slight change of subject, but there is one thing about this that bothered
me. After DD's death Harry is thinking about the fact that he has never been
to a funeral, because there was no physical remains left of SB. 

In our world,  we have plenty of funerals where a body was never recovered,
I find that these memorials are an important part of the grieving process
and quite frankly I'm shocked that they never did anything for SB.
Especially considering the emotional impact it had on Harry and co.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]