The Look Of Triumph

[Jessica]

No: HPFGUIDX 159495

 Katherine Coble:
>> Suppose that Harry was a horcrux, created that night at Godric's
 Hollow.  But then further suppose that by using Harry's blood for
 his resurrection in the graveyard at Little Hangleton, Voldemort
 unknowingly invalidated Harry's position as  Horcrux.  In other
 words, Voldemort already took back that part of his soul. <<

 Magpie:
>> But wouldn't Dumbledore have to have then told Harry that in HBP
when he's telling him about Horcruxes?  <snip> He goes through all
the possibilities in his mind and never mentions thinking Harry was
a Horcrux that's already been destroyed. <snip> I don't think he'd
pretend to consider other Horcruxes if his look of triumph was over
the Harrycrux's destruction. <<


Jessica:
I love this theory because I am so hoping Harry doesn't die!  I was
almost there myself when I reread the books but couldn't put my
finger on it.  As for Dumbledore, maybe he wasn't sure?  Maybe he
knew it was no longer in Harry, so he didn't mention it.  But, he may
have thought Voldemort placed it somewhere else (the question of why
Nagini was circling the graveyard that night?)  So, it could be that
Nagini has the Horcrux now.
Jessica