Snape is still working for Dumbledore in book 6

[a_svirn]

No: HPFGUIDX 159638

> Random832
> I think a key 'lesson' we see in the books is that the ministry
> defines whatever it feels like as being dark or not. If the UV is 
only
> dark when used for certain purposes, why not also AK? Surely it would
> not be dark as a method of execution of murderers, it'd certainly be
> more humane/painless than the dementor's kiss. or even if then, still
> not for something as mundane as slaughtering livestock.

a_svirn:
Well, maybe it's not Dark in all those cases? I mean, Crouch Jr. did 
use all three unforgivables on spiders and the Imperius on his 
students. Granted, he was a villain in disguise, but he did not blow 
his cover by doing so. And his father authorised Aurors to use 
unforgivables as they saw fit.