Sympathy to the characters? Fake Moody, Weasleys, Hermione

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 159797

> > > Alla:
> > > Now, Hermione is actually more interesting situation. I am also 
pretty
> > > safe at betting that she should not worry you, etc, **but** the 
main
> > > reason I am doing so is because JKR as much as called Hermione 
her
> > > alter ego and I sincerely doubt that she would make her alter 
ego
> evil.
> > 
> Random832:
> > I dunno (maybe not evil, but like you say below, idiotic) - she 
did
> > make her a hypocrite. Not ministry approved, indeed! What you're
> > saying is basically because Hermione's the author's favorite 
character
> > / "alter ego" / whatever, she can't have any flaws - you're
> > effectively asking for "Hermione Sue". When in reality, she has
> > already been shown to have flaws.
> 
> 
> Renee:
> Eh, I don't think I'm following this. Is claiming that someone won't
> turn evil the same as claiming they're flawless? Or did you snip
> something essential here?
>

Alla:

leaving all the post in there, because I need to clarify and 
basically to say that yes, you are right Renee.

Nowhere did I say that because Hermione is JKR admitted alter-ego she 
cannot have any flaws.

What I **did** say is that this is the reason that she won't turn 
evil. I guess it can be considered a flaw, but personally I consider 
evilness to be um, the ultimate flaw. So, to hopefully make myself 
clear I am betting that Hermione can have **any** flaws, except 
becoming the follower of Voldemort.

Moreover, I thought I was expressing myself clear enough that Ieven 
would see a potential of Hermione doing something very bad, but for 
the fact that she is JKR alter-ego.

So, certainly am not asking for Hermione Sue and do not think she 
exists :)

Alla