The Scar

[J]

No: HPFGUIDX 159859

Erica:
I don't believe that Harry is a horcrux. Voldemort has taken great
lenghts to stay alive. Why would he make the person he is trying to
kill a horcrux. Voldemort chooses what becomes a horcrux. Why would he
have choosen Harry if he was going to kill him. 

------------------------------------------

Jeremiah:
HERE! HERE!!!! That's exactly why I think the "accidental" horcrux theory is a load of horse pucky. (Sorry... I don't mean to offend those of you who believe in that theory, but there are huge flaws).
Some say that Lily and James' deaths would make the whole "Harry the Horcrux Who Lived" theory plausible would have to remember that we don't know how one is made but we know it isn't easy. I would think that Dumbledore would have at least suspected this idea and would have told Harry (since he was in "untrustworthy" waters at the time).
The idea is fun but doesn't pan out. JKR would have a whole lot of explaining to do if this was her intention and I don't think a book could be long enough to incorporate that idea as well as the many others that need tidying up in this series.