Fawkes/the two planned for death: Veil

finwitch finwitch at yahoo.com
Fri Oct 20 12:16:44 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 160038

> 
> Jenni:
> I think Fawkes could help Harry. But I'm also wondering something
> else. Fawkes was Dumbledore's pet. Was this because Fawkes chose
> Dumbledore or because Dumbledore chose Fawkes? If Fawkes can choose
> his 'master', I wonder if he will choose Harry!

Finwitch:

Well, certainly I think Faweks will help Harry - if only because of 
Harry's loyalty to Dumbledore even *after* Dumbledore died...

I think the Boa from zoo will return to the picture as well.

But something else - remember how JKR gave the hint about some she 
had planned to die to avoid that? I think that those two might be the 
two whose voices Harry heard from behind the Veil. Sirius & Ron that 
is. Sirius, where he is, beyond, is not exactly alive -- nor quite 
dead. Stuck in-between more like -- in what I believe Dumbledore 
referred to as 'worse than death'. And um - I don't think anyone 
wants Voldemort as a ghost, so he must be forced to the beyond...

I think that Aberforth was stuck thus once, and as Albus defeated 
Grindelwald he brought Aberforth back. Now Harry can defeat Voldemort 
and bring Sirius back (otherwise Harry would die).

(As for why-- what else could have happened to make Albus doubt his 
brother's literacy?)

So I think Sirius is saved from the destiny of death. Ron will need 
similar rescue - and this time Bella (who *Would* be willing to risk 
it all to bring Voldemort back) will be the one left there.

Finwitch






More information about the HPforGrownups archive