I don't think that Harry will die

dumbledore11214 dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Sun Oct 22 01:58:25 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 160135

> pumpkinpastie18:
> > Because Harry = hope.
> 
> Sarah:
> 
> But if he = hope now, what will he = after his job is done, is my
> question.  I'd rather see him go out in a blaze of glory, than end 
up
> washed up.  Tons of hero stories end up with the hero joining the
> glorious dead after successfully completing their quests.  Neo,
> Hercules, the Pevensies, Frodo and Harry would all be more boring 
if
> they went home and got government jobs after.

Alla:

Why boring? I do not agree at all - normal happy life, something 
that Harry craves IMO, something that would be of the sort of the 
reward, besides if you do not like reading about his post Voldemort 
**life** which I hope will exist, I am sure JKR will deal with it in 
a few sentences in epilogue - married Ginny, had twelve kids, 
etc :), or at least that is the epilogue I want to see,hehe.

Sara: 
> WWJKRD?  Well, she's consistently given quotes to the effect that 
what
> makes anyone think Harry lives that long?  And that she has to 
write
> what she set out to write.

Alla:

She never said AFAIK that she will kill Harry though. She teases all 
the time, yes, she asks that questions, she recently flat out 
refused to tell anybody what is going to happen to Harry, so I am 
not sure at all that we know what she set out to write.


IMO of course,

Alla, who certainly joins Geoff in "let Harry live" club and  for 
whom Harry's death is the only plot twist which would stop her from 
reading the series again - just too depressing, sorry.

 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive