[HPforGrownups] Re: Fawkes

[Lana]

No: HPFGUIDX 160247



  >Lana writes:

  >I really don't think that the feather has anything to do with them >being drawn together. 

  >Fawkes came to Harry's aid not because of the wand, but because of >his loyalty to Dumbledore. The wand really doesn't play a role in >how the bond was formed. 

  >If it did, then Fawkes would show the same loyalty to Voldermort >and I just cannot see that happening.

  >Nancy writes:
  >Lana and all, I'd have to disagree with this theory. After all, Harry >distinguishes himself from LV in that he uses his free will to chose to >do good. I think Fawkes follows this as his cue.
  >In similar vain, the ?rumor as to loss of Hedgewig and replacement >of feathered friend... should we discount the Hippogryph?
  >I just still think ,however that Fawkes will play a greater roll, >maybe to guide Harry in the secrets in DD office?
  >Nancy


  Lana Writes:
    Not sure which "theory" you disagree with.  Are you saying you think that it does or doesn't have to do with the feather?  I personally don't think it has anything to do with the feather in the wands. 

  I think that Fawkes bonded with Harry thru his devotion to DD.  But I also agree that it has to do with his choice to do good.  Fawkes is the symbol of all things good.  At least that is what is portrayed to me.  So of course he will follow and defend what is good.  Harry has proven that and Fawkes knows it.

   I also am not sure that Harry is going to lose Hedwig.  I think that he will just gain another.  Of course there is the chance that Hedwig gets intercepted and killed, but really...  what would that accomplish to the story.  The killing of an owl.. Seems a bit strange to me.  Unlikely as well.

  Hugs,  Lana



   

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]