Dumbledore Horcrux?

[Nicole M. Angle]

No: HPFGUIDX 160298

Nicole:

  >> Personally, I don't think DD would be capable. A horcrux 
  is so dark and terrible it's not mentioned in any Hogwarts book, 
  except to say how dark and terrible it is. Not to mention, DD 
  would have to kill someone to create a horcrux, and considering 
  he wouldn't even kill Voldy, I don't think he would.

Amy:

  You are correct ... we were talking about this here at work, 
  and one of the customers said the same as you, but I am still 
  confused ... if you accept the possibility of Snape and DD 
  working together, and it being Snape's job to kill DD just to 
  clear the way for Harry to kill LV, then is Harry being used 
  as a pawn to do the work?, or does DD intend Snape to mentor 
  Harry (after of course, Harry apologizes to Snape for the way 
  his father treated Snape during their youth?) after taking out 
  LV, assuming Harry lives of course.

  It just seemed a waste to kill DD when he was mentoring Harry 
  the way he was.



Nicole:

  In that, your assuming that Snape killed DD for Harry to kill Voldy, which is one theory in thousands.  Then yeah, too little of a reason, but I think there is so much more to it.  There has to be, JK wouldn't just kill DD for that little.   On Snape tutoring Harry, I don't think there is enough time for that in 1 book.  In book 7, we have quite a few things that will happen. 1. We should find out why DD died & why Snape did it/but I don't think we will get an explination of that until the very end, so no time for tutoring.2.  The end will most likely take at least the last 1/4 of the book to build to. 3. JK has said we will find out a little about Lily. 4. Find 4? horocrux,. 5 possible do this all while at Hogwarts.. Too much in book 7 that I can't wait to read! But there are lots of unsolved issues open to fill.  Bellatrix better die, Peter Pettigrew somehow has to fulfill his life debt to Harry from PoA, Snape, good/bad?, Who dies, who lives, Fleur & Bills wedding, Gosh, you think about everything that we are still trying to figure out, how will it all be finished in one book?

  And find out who RAB is...

  Nicole A