Dumbledore and Polyjuice

twitterpatedbabykoala mcdumbledore at juno.com
Fri Oct 27 03:16:55 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 160436

Snape's Witch:
>      If Snape is a polyjuiced Dumbledore then who is the man with  
>  Harry in Chapters 3 and 4?  Surely not Snape?  No, no, no.




I don't have the book in front of me right now, so I can't speak to 
chapters 3 and 4 specifically, but I will say that something that 
struck me overwhelmingly in HBP was Dumbledore's newfound tendency to 
gloat.  It was subtle, in most respects, but that - more than anything 
else (the Unbreakable Vow, the stuff on the Astronomy tower) - made me 
suspicious of a Polyjuice situation right away.  Maybe tomorrow I'll 
have a minute to dig out the book and give some canon examples of 
Dumbledore's oddly Snape-like self aggrandizement, or maybe some kind 
soul who noticed the same thing and has a few minutes tonight will do 
it for me?

Becca








More information about the HPforGrownups archive