The ends justifying the means (was Re: Views of Hermione.)

[juli17 at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 160578

Eggplant wrote:

Of all  the mistakes Harry has made over 6 books I believe the single
biggest one  was made in book 3 when he stopped Lupin and Black from
doing what needed  to be done. Voldemort would not have been able to
return and countless  people would still be alive.
Julie:
And I guess the best thing Snape ever did was to reveal the prophecy 
to Voldemort, since that act resulted in Voldemort becoming  Vapormort,
the first war (which the good side *was* losing) coming to an end,  and
countless lives being saved. That is, by your logic that the ends  justify
the means and intent means nothing.
 
Darn Harry for undoing all of Snape's good work! (*sarcasm alert*)
 
Julie,  

 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]