Views of Hermione.

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 160598

Leah:
> Marietta is not a hero, neither is Hermione a villain. She is a 
> brave and clever girl who needs to think some things over more 
> carefully.

Alla:

Absolutely, I agree with that.

Leah:
<SNIP> 
> She is scared and she does 
> wrong, for which action you would be happy to see her dead.      

Alla:

Of course not, not everybody thinks that :) All that I am saying 
that I would not want Marietta to go UNpunished, but I certainly not 
want her dead.


Lea:
> If Marietta had spilled the beans in Umbridge's office, I am not 
> convinced it would have been beyond the powers of Albus Dumbledore 
> to have remedied the situation. 

Alla:

With that I completely disagree, otherwise Dumbledore would not have 
to leave the school, IMO of course. I think he remedied as best as 
he could.


Lea:
 And let's not forget that everyone 
> in DA knew they were doing something illegal and were taking the 
> risk of discovery and betrayal.

Alla:

Yes, but wouldn't you agree that they also had a right to protect 
themselves against discovery and betrayal?

JMO,

Alla