[HPforGrownups] OoP clues?

[Kemper]

No: HPFGUIDX 157957

> Carol:
>
> It seems to me that we're in desperate need of a new topic again, so
> here's my attempt to start a new thread. JKR has indicated that we
> should look at OoP, which she concedes is a little too long, for clues:
>
> JKR: <snip>  <snip>
>
> Carol resumes:
> So all the subplots are necessary for the resolution--house elfs and
> boggarts and all. What do those who think Phoenix is a "bad" book with
> a lot of wasted pages think should have been cut because it won't play
> a part in book seven? And what do OoP's defenders think will prove to
> be important besides the locket that won't open and the Veil and the
> Love Room in the DoM?
> ...
> 


Kemper now:

I hate Gwarp and the chapter 'Hagrid's Tale' (I immediately thought of
Chaucer but can't see how it relates to any of his tales).

I really don't know how to add any more.  I think Hagrid's tale could've
been hella edited... but I'm no editor.

Also... Aberforth seems like a line of questioning, but those who talk about
him and his actual scenes are very limited.

That's all I got in the 'right now'.

Kemper


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]