Support for parents of Muggleborns; Magic late in life
Bruce Alan Wilson
bawilson at citynet.net
Sun Sep 10 04:30:58 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 158112
Ceridwen:
"Though, I would suggest that if Petunia and Vernon were supported by
the WW, perhaps the abuse would not have happened. I'm only saying
perhaps, because we can't know. But knowing that they had some
recourse when Harry displayed accidental magic might have relieved
stress, which also contributes to abusive situations, if I recall
correctly. And knowing that someone would be around to check and
have 'Tea with Petunia' (who said that? love it, sounds like an
afternoon gossip program on TV!) would curtail some more overt
abuses, too, in my opinion."
BAW:
How do we know that there isn't such a system? Hermione's parents
don't seem to be phased. Perhaps the Dursleys are a special case;
perhaps one of the conditions on which Petunia accepted him was that
there be NO contact with the Wizardling world until it was time for
Harry to go to Hogwarts.
The fact is that there is a great deal about the Wizarding world
that we don't know; JKR has not seen fit to tell us because it has
not been relevant to the plot.
Tonks:
"Someone "late in life" could be a teenager too old to begin at
Hogwarts. It could be Dudley.
Another reason to suspect Dudley is that Petunia is his mother and
Magic does run in her family as a dormant gene or something. "
BAW:
JKR has said that it will NOT be either Dudley or Petunia.
Personally, I think it will be Uncle Vernon, if only because it
would be a huge kick in the pants for him. Imagine him carefully
interrogating Dudley's girlfriends to try to find out if they have
any Wizardling blood without actually asking in so many words! The
girls would probably think that he was a total nut case and run
fast and far.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive