JKR site update SPOILERS

[Janette]

No: HPFGUIDX 158902

> > Ceridwen:
> > She was very tricky with this one, with our help.  We all *know*
> the
> > question refers to Godrick's Hollow.  We assume this is what she
> means
> > as well.  But, she doesn't say.  He could have been anywhere on
> earth
> > that night, since GH is a place on earth, he could have been
> there.
> > But, since in her universe that was a Tuesday night, I think he was
> > probably at Hogwarts, maybe even swooping through the halls
> catching
> > students out after curfew.


montims:

wasn't it Halloween?  So he should have been at the feast...  Or have I got
that wrong?

Though I do think it's interesting how she is playing up the cloak angle -
first she says it is a crucial point, then a few days later she updates her
website to say it wasn't Snape under the cloak.  So much information in such
a short time - it is starting to smell a little fishy to me - do red
herrings smell?  Or has she been reading forum comments and people have got
too close, so she's trying a bit of smoke and mirrors to divert them...


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]