Snape: ESE or DDM?

fireflyseason2 lydiafrench at gmail.com
Thu Apr 5 04:30:46 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 167100

 Bart wrote:
> A major mystery through the books was: Why did Dumbledore
trust Snape so much? \
> And I just don't believe that JKR is playing a practical
joke on the audience.
> Therefore, I am willing to go through Rowlingish hoops of
logic to explain how Snape was and still is DDM.


I believe that we will be made privy to a as yet unseen memory
of Snape's in which we discover the reason for DD hard and fast
faith in Snape's intentions. The one thing that DD values above
all else is the power of love and so I assume that will be
involved. Perhaps a hidden yet deep love of Snape for Lily. She
who was his champion and seemed to dislike the same side of
James that Snape despised. She may have been Snape's first and
only and clearly unrequited love. Who knows, it may even bring
us round again to the importance of her eyes.

Firefly
PS.Either way, Snape is DDM and he DID NOT kill DD. DD would
never have asked him too, for that would have been murder and
split his soul.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive