[HPforGrownups] The Prank in DH (was Re: Predictions for the End (what I think, hope and know)

[Sherry Gomes]

No: HPFGUIDX 167326

wynnleaf
Actually, Snape's comments about the Marauder's have been collaborated by
several pieces of evidence.  He said that James was arrogant and the
Pensieve scene appeared to collaborate that.  He said that James used his
own spells against him, and that was collaborated in the Pensieve scene.  He
said that the Marauders thought they were above the rules.  While we don't
know what they actually *thought*, we do know that they broke the rules a
great deal and had lots of detentions -- apparently far more than Snape
since Harry never seems to run across a detention for Snape in the files.  


Sherry now:

And are we supposed to believe that Snape let Harry see just random
detentions?  I'm confident that he purposely made sure Harry saw as many
with his father- as possible-an extremely cruel, childish and vindictive
punishment by the way, in my opinion--and I'm just as sure he made sure
there were no detentions for his precious self in the things he had Harry go
through.

Sherry