Absolute Crazy Thought - Harry Arisen

Steve bboyminn at yahoo.com
Thu Apr 19 06:59:44 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 167733

This thought just popped into my head, and I thought I
would pass it on. I'm not even sure I believe it, but it
is something to think about. 

This came up from the "Harry and his Parent's Graves"
thread. It occurs to me that if we now know the location
of Harry parent's graves, then we know the location of
the 'Bones of His Father'. We also know from experience
what those bone can be used for.

People have no problem speculating that Harry is,
whether intended or accidental, Voldemort's Horcrux,
but why can't it be the other way around. Why can't
Voldemort accidentally be Harry's Horcrux? Or perhaps,
by taking a bit of Harry's blood Voldemort has also
taken a bit of Harry's spirit. 

Let's say about half way through the book, Voldemort
seems to kill Harry, but Harry doesn't leave this 
earth. He only leaves his body. His soul lingers on, 
tied by some accidental horcrux. 

Now we need a way to get our hero back into the story.
Perhaps, Snape and/or Wormtail can supply 'flesh of a
servant', and the other can provide 'blood of an 
enemy'. Of course, there are plenty of other candidates
for either. Lupin could provide 'flesh'; Draco could 
provide 'blood', and many other combinations.

Much to Voldemort's suprise, Harry comes back from the
dead, in the flesh, fully realized. Now Voldemort is
truly dealing with an 'equal'. In the same sense that
Voldemort has /conquered/ death, so has Harry.

The tricky part is that this puts them at a stalemate 
rather than a victory. So, now we need a way for the
reborn Harry to break the stalemate. I haven't quite 
got that part figure out yet. Though perhaps Harry in
an disembodied form will be well suited to spy on 
Voldemort and will learn the secret of the remaining
Horcruxes, and he will use that knowledge to defeat
Voldemort.

Other possibilities now exist as well, maybe Harry in 
his disembodied form possesses Voldemort, drags him
behind the Veil, and returns using Sirius's body. Then
at some later time the New Body (Blood, Flesh, & Bone)
Spell is used to essentially raise Harry from the dead.
So that everyone can live happily ever after. Either of
these are certainly a plot twist that most fans, other
that oddballs like me, would think of.

I'm not saying it's true, it was just a thought, and I 
did say it was a Crazy thought, none the less, there it
is. And for the record, far crazier thought that this
have been considered. 

Steve/bboyminn





More information about the HPforGrownups archive