Absolute Crazy Thought - Harry Arisen
Steve
bboyminn at yahoo.com
Thu Apr 19 23:15:31 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 167761
--- "Bruce Alan Wilson" <bawilson at ...> wrote:
>
> I get the impression is that the Blood Flesh & Bone
> spell is a piece of horrid Black wizardry that no
> respectable mage would ever consider having anything to
> do with.
>
> Bruce Alan Wilson
>
bboyminn:
Here's the thing, this unlikely theory assumes that Harry
has no idea that a Horcrux exists for him. When Voldemort
cast the killing curse against him, Harry full expects
to die. But what happens if he doesn't?
What happens if Harry is trapped in the in-between world
of 'vapor!Harry'? He is unable to cross over to his
'eternal reward', and is unable to manifest himself in
the material world. Is that really how you want Harry to
remain?
Now starting from this point, what are you willing to do
to get Harry back? What are you willing to assist Harry
in doing, for Harry to return to defeat Voldemort?
Keep in mind that in this case, the 'flesh of a servant'
doesn't have to be a hand. It could be just the very tip
of a finger; not even enough to permanently damage the
finger. The 'blood of an enemy forcibly taken' could
simply be Draco allowing Ron to forcibly take some of
his blood. There really is a range of gray here that
needs to be considered.
So, start from that point. Voldemort /kills/ Harry but
Harry doesn't die. He remains on earth in a bodiless
form. Now what are you willing to do to get Harry back?
How dark does 'Blood, Flesh & Bone' seem in this context?
Steve/bboyminn
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive