Lily the popular girl
va32h
va32h at comcast.net
Wed Apr 25 16:51:42 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 167938
> Montavilla47:
> I just have to ask this, because I've run into this on other forums
and it kind of bugs me. I know that Harry gets angry that Merope
didn't do more to keep herself healthy and that Dumbledore then makes a
> comparison, saying the Merope didn't have Lily's courage.
>
> But can we really say that Merope didn't choose her child's life over
her own? If there really is any choice about dying in childbirth.
>
va32h:
Harry expresses his surprise in response to Dumbledore's statement that
Merope didn't even lift her wand to save her own life - which suggests
to me that witch could use magic to protect her health or at least
Dumbledore thought that Merope could have.
va32h
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive