Snape finding Lily's letter

[Cathy Drolet]

No: HPFGUIDX 174093

Christy said:
"Even if he had no contact with the house before OOTP, Lupin could have cleaned out Sirius's flat after his went to prison and kept things he thought were important, esp. things that reminded him of the good times.."

Oh, yes, firmly believe that Lupin, who believed Sirius to be the traitor who caused James and Lily to be murdered, and their son put into the protective custody of his muggle relatives, would go back to Sirius' flat and gather up his personal effects.  Not!  I expect Lupin woud have had his own mementos of the good times and he never expected Sirius to come out of Azkaban...or at least not in any shape to care about personal effects.

Too many hoops to jump through, for me, to make the letter being at 12 GP believable.

CathyD

 

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]