Who else should have been at 9 3/4 at the end of the book?
Geoff Bannister
gbannister10 at tiscali.co.uk
Thu Aug 2 08:41:15 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 174223
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Mellanie Crowther <magpye29 at ...> wrote:
Mellanie
> I'm new here, but I would have liked to have seen George, and I'm
intrigued by something I read where JKR suggested that Luna and Neville
could have ended up together. I'm also with those who wanted to see
Dudley there, and my favorite HP movie hottie, Oliver Wood.
Geoff:
Thinking about the various responses to this question, I would like to
offer a couple of comments.
In the brief and minimalist epilogue which JKR has used to replace
her original ideas and which tells us hardly anything, we do not know
who might be there because it's not germane to the story.
We know from each reference to the Express in the books that the
platform at Kings Cross is always crowded. So? Let me give a parallel
example. At this time of year, the Sunday morning service at my church
is full - maybe 180-200 people because in addition to our own folk, we
get a lot of holidaymakers in the area. I come home and my wife might
say to me, "I didn't see Y and Z this morning. I wonder if they're away?"
My reply might be "No. I spoke to Y after the service." There could easily
be lots of folk we know there but who just don't feature in the meetings
or conversations.
Some people suggested Hagrid might be there. However, don't forget this
is /not/ the first time the Potters have been there for the Hogwarts Express.
James is already a pupil at the school...
It's just a "normal" departure if such a thing exists around Harry. :-)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive