Hagrid's Age WAS: Who else should have been at 9 3/4 at the end of the book?

Sherry Sherry at PebTech.net
Thu Aug 2 13:24:47 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 174236

> Lisa:
> 
> Well, Hagrid lives at Hogwarts, so as long as he was still alive, James 
> could visit him; he wouldn't necessarily still be Groundskeeper/Care of 
> Magical Creatures professor.  As for a life span -- I was under the 
> impression that giants didn't live very long ... but I don't know why I 
> think that, and I'm too lazy to pull out HBP, LOL! 

Amontillada:

I'm not sure, but I have an impression that has more to do with their
tendency to fight and harm each other, not with early death from
natural causes. If many giants die young from battle or injuries, it
would reduce the average life expectancy.

 But JKR said 
> McGonagal, a wizard only three years older than Hagrid (according to 
> the Lexicon's calculations), was "getting on" in years and wasn't 
> headmaster (or teacher, I assume) 

Amontillada:

I've wondered about that assumption. It may be that McGonagal chose to
leave the headmaster's office and return her energies to teaching. A
teacher with her great skill at Transfiguration may be harder to find
than an able headmaster.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive