Hermione's parents (was Re: A Sense of Betrayal )/Luna's Creepy Father

[Lisa]

No: HPFGUIDX 174348

 Magpie:
> The problem is Hermione deciding on her own to rob someone else of 
> their lives without their consent or even thinking of it as far as 
> we know, not that she would rather never see them again than have 
> them murdered. 

Lisa:

But that was the point of my post that you quoted:  we don't know that 
she decided this on her own.  All we know is that it was done.  She 
could've given them a choice, just like the Dursleys were given a 
choice.

Lisa