Where was Snape?
melhersheybar
mhersheybar at hotmail.com
Tue Aug 7 15:41:03 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 174721
I admit I have not read every post in the last two weeks, but I have
not seen a discussion of this in the ones I have read. My question
is, where was Snape between the time he "did a bunk" prior to the
start of the first battle for Hogwarts and the time he showed up in
the Shrieking Shack? We don't have an answer from the book, and his
absence has bothered me.
It does not appear that he realized at the time he fled that VD has
started keeping Nagini close by because he does not immediately go
to find Harry and give him the last bit of information that Harry
contains a piece of VD's soul. So he runs off, doesn't go to VD,
doesn't fight on the side of the Death Eaters, and yet, Lucius is
able to easily find him when VD asks him to. Only then does he
realize that, "whoops, I better go find Harry" before it is too
late. Does he realize at that point that VD is about to kill him?
I don't know, but it seems so.
Absent any other explanation, I have to conclude the Jo purposefully
blurred the plot here so that the whole "passing of the memories"
and Prince's Tale could take place in a way that made it possible
for Harry to accept and believe the information. I know that a lot
of people have commented about how lucky it was that Harry was in
the right place in the Shrieking Shack at the right time, and how
close he came to missing this crucial piece of info altogether. But
what is alternative? What if Snape had been able to simply find
Harry wandering the grounds and tried to give him the information?
There is no way Harry would have believed him, he probably would
have tried to kill him, and the information would have been lost
forever.
Mel
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive