Revenge, Greek tragedies & the heart (Re: Molly's "revenge" )

Jen Reese stevejjen at earthlink.net
Wed Aug 8 18:34:45 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 174833

Jen:
> In the end, I'd say that Harry & Co., like Dumbledore and the Order 
> before them, are not the Ultimate Right in the WW so much as *more* 
> right than those they are opposing.  Trying to stop cycles of 
> violence, attempting to do so by making choices for right action more 
> often than not, taking small steps against the various centuries-old 
> rifts in the WW...all are meaningful and worth doing if only because 
> the alternative, following the path Aberforth recommended and 
> disregarded himself <g>, is to do nothing.  

Jen:  Correcting myself here because I messed up something pretty big. 
I didn't mean to say Voldemort was right and Dumbledore et. al. are 
simply more right, lol. 

I was trying to explain that I don't see Harry or anyone connected to 
Dumbledore as the moral arbiters of justice in the WW.  It's more that 
they appear to be further along the path of what a just society looks 
like and how people should act in such a society rather than some of 
those they oppose, people/creatures who aren't followers of Voldemort 
but also not supportive of Dumbledore.  

Jen, noting this explanation takes place out of context from her 
initial post and is better read after the first one. 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive