[HPforGrownups] Re: Good and Bad Slytherins

Tenne tenne at redshift.bc.ca
Fri Aug 10 20:06:00 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 175065

Sherry Bailey says: 
> Slytherins. Never forget that HARRY almost got sorted to Slytherin! 
> So HE would have been a "good Slytherin" if he hadn't been biased 
> against that house by Ron on the train, and begged the Hat not to 
> put him there. (Heck, maybe he'd have led a Slytherin reform 
> movement!)


Is it canon that Harry would have been sorted into Slytherin?  I remember it that he said he didn't want to go to Slytherin before the hat said he was being sorted there.  As well, Hermione said that the hat considered her for Ravenclaw before putting her into Gryffindor.  DD told Harry he was a true heir to Gryffindor because he could pull the sword from the hat.  Would the sorting hat put a true heir to Gryffindor into Slytherin?

Terri




More information about the HPforGrownups archive