Dumbledore and the slaughtered pig, also featuring logic

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 175181

va32h: Wrote:

> Take GoF - a common argument has been that
> Fake!Moody should have just made a book or
> a quill into  portkey and used that to get
> Harry on the first or second day of class.
> The whole triwizard tournament is a contrivance. 

I've always felt Rowling should have had Voldemort say something like
this to his death eaters in the graveyard:

"There is a powerful spell preventing port keys from working at
Hogwarts but during the Tri Wizard Tournament people would be arriving
from all over the world so I knew the spell would have to be
temporarily removed, if not in the castle itself at least on the
grounds. It also amused me to have Harry Potter whisked away to his
doom at the very instant he thinks he's going to attain his greatest
triumph. And I did it right under Dumbledore's nose with the entire
world watching, people can now see with their own eyes which one of us
is more powerful."

Eggplant Gellert Grindelwald