Hermione's parents.

eggplant107 eggplant107 at hotmail.com
Tue Aug 14 04:46:53 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 175350

sistermagpie Wrote: 

> How about a Fidelius charm 

So Hermione casts a Fidelius charm on her house and imprisons her
parents there for nearly a year where they can only conclude that
their daughter has turned into a psychopath. If she'd done that I have
a hunch I'd see a message or two in this group expressing some slight
reservations over her actions.

> there's no indication anything bad
> would have happened to the Grangers 

That I believe is pure unadulterated nonsense. Of course something bad
would happen to the Grangers, something very bad indeed!

> they didn't go after the Weasleys 

Huh? They did go after the Weasleys as soon as they found out Ron was
on the run with Harry.

> They can't possibly make an informed decision why? 

Because as I've said before they don't and cannot know what the hell
is going on.

> How is it that Ron's parents are able
> to make the same decision? 

Because Ron's parents have knowledge and abilities that Hermione's
parents do not have and know how to survive in a culture that would be
totally alien to the Grangers. 

> I didn't say that Hermione didn't
> do the logical thing

Then what are we arguing about? 

 Eggplant Gellert Grindelwald     
 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive