Harry the author
rt11guru
ken.fruit at gmail.com
Wed Aug 15 09:50:09 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 175450
guru:
I would think that if Snape had been teaching his versions of the
recipes, that Harry would have recognized them when he saw the
notations in the book.
Melissa :
Not necessarily. My handwriting at 43 years of age is vastly
different to what it was when I was in 17 and in high school. So I
can see how Harry might not recognize the notations.
guru:
Clarification: I was thinking more of content than of form.
Having spent a lot of time reading the book, Harry would have
recognized that Snape taught them the modified versions of formulas,
not the original versions from the book.
I know that this is an advanced class with an advanced text, but as
with most textbooks, there would probably have been overlap with
previously taught material.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive