Why fly when you can apparate?

sonjaaiston sonjaaiston at yahoo.com
Thu Aug 16 04:24:00 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 175552

Snip:
> Allie :

> Maybe that's why Lily couldn't apparate away with baby Harry, how 
> could a baby hold its breath long enough to get anywhere?  
> Apparation could kill it.  (I think I've seen that theory here 
> before, but not the holding breath part of it.)  (And I think we're 
> told that Lily didn't have her wand, do you need a wand to apparate?)

Me:
At first, I didn't think you needed a wand to apparate.  Then, when 
Harry, Ron, and Hermione were at the MOM and helped the Muggle-borns 
escape, Harry said, "Who's got wands?"  Then, "Okay, all of you who 
haven't got wands need to attach yourself to somebody who has.  We'll 
need to be fast before they stop us."  Soon after going through the 
lifts and the toilets, they apparated.  I took this to mean they needed 
a wand to apparate.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive