What things that you wanted did you get? (was: Killing Harry)

cubfanbudwoman susiequsie23 at sbcglobal.net
Thu Aug 16 15:50:16 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 175567

SSSusan:
>> Anyone else care to bite?

marion11111:
> Predicted, wanted and got::
> <snip most of list, to leave this:> 
> Horcrux!Tiara in the RoR

SSSusan:
I forgot to put that in my list yesterday!  This was one of the 
things I did get down in TK's prediction contest and hoped would come 
to fruition. :)


marion11111:
> Horcrux!Harry

SSSusan:
This was one I decidedly did NOT want, going in.  The way she did it, 
though, I found that I didn't mind it.  (Well, other than DD's role 
in predicting/interpreting it but not sharing that!)


marion11111:
> Ollivander held hostage by LV

SSSusan:
I thought he had been taken by Voldy, too, though I thought it was 
because he owned Rowena Ravenclaw's wand. Whooops.

And I can't believe I forgot to mention something else that I 
*really* hoped for and got: NO MORE TIME-TURNING.  Yippee!!  I so 
didn't want that to come back.  Polyjuice potion, I could live with.  
TT! gives me headaches and reads so much more like deus ex machina 
(even if it's not) than PJP, etc.


Marion11111:
> Absolutely surprised by:
<snip>
> DD being such a B******
> Lupin being such a B******
> Kreacher being cute
> Dudley being cute

SSSusan:
Hee.  Have to love how you presented these! 

marion11111:
> Ministry's quick and complete take-over of Hogwarts
> Snape as headmaster

SSSusan:
I didn't see this coming at all either!  In fact, I'm dying to see 
the results of TK's contest, because I'm curious if *anyone* 
predicted Snape as Headmaster.  I really thought he'd be on the run 
at the start of the book.

marion11111:
> The horrifying snake in Bathilda - still causing nightmares

SSSusan:
Man, that creeped me out.  The first time I read the scene, I wasn't 
even sure what was happening.  JKR made that scene awfully visceral, 
imo: the stench of the place (including the bedpan, ick!), the dust, 
the body falling away as Nagini emerged from the neck... just, gross!

Siriusly Snapey Susan






More information about the HPforGrownups archive