need help for all of my confuse!
rawood3
rawood3 at yahoo.com
Fri Aug 17 20:01:19 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 175682
> Jasmine here:
> The Avada Kedavra spell rebounded on Voldy because the elder wand
> would not curse its true master, Harry Potter. As Harry explained to
> Voldemort that he overpowered Draco weeks ago and took his wand from
> him.
>
I have had an issue with the topic of Harry being the Elder Wand's
true master. Harry never actually took the Elder Wand from Draco so
how could he be the EW's true master? Harry disarmed Draco and took
his personal wand sure, however, the Elder Wand was in Dumbledore's
tomb. I'll have to check the text of Olivander's explanation of
wandlore again, but in my opinion Harry was never the EW's true
master, Draco should still be the wand's true master as he did take it
from Dumbledore by disarming him.
On the other hand, Voldy was not the true master of the EW when he
used AD on Harry, but Harry was the true master of Draco's wand and
thus a true master's Expelliarmus overpowered Voldy's AD.
Russ
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive