Harry using Crucio.

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 175738

 "urghiggi" <urghiggi at ...> wrote:

> I still can't see how 'stupefy' or
> 'petrificus totalus' wouldn't have 
> worked equally well in the Carrow 
> incident, without the moral issues
> of torture raised by crucio.
 
If a moral issue is raised in that scene it is caused by war not by
the crucio. In a real war if a commando infiltrated into the enemy
camp and needed to put a high ranking enemy official out of action he
would not knock him out, he would no tie him up, he would kill him.
Dead dead dead! There is absolutely no doubt about it. Carrow got very
lightly at Harry's hands, too lightly to be entirely realistic but
then this is a fantasy. 

 Eggplant Gellert Grindelwald