The Fundamental Message of the HP books?

Dana ida3 at planet.nl
Sun Aug 19 10:36:39 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 175793

Jen: 
> He's not in the same situation with Snape.  Besides the above 
> complications, he expects Snape will become Master of the Elder 
> Wand.  I have no idea what benefit that confers and wish someone 
> would explain it to me.  It does sound beneficial from the way 
> Dumbledore and Harry discuss it in the King's Cross chapter.

Dana:
Although the wand thing is highly confusing in its rules but from 
what I understood of it, DD did not want Snape to be the rightful 
owner in the sense that he could use its power. The death was 
arranged and therefore Snape would technically not have defeated the 
owner of the wand. So Snape would, like LV, have owned the wand but 
not the powers contained within it. It would from then on just be a 
normal wand just like any other with no one ever again being able to 
defeat the owner for its powers because DD had been its last rightful 
owner and because he was dead, he could never be fought for it. 

That as I take it was DD's plan but Draco disarming DD made him its 
rightful owner. 

Dana






More information about the HPforGrownups archive