Kings Cross..... The end???

jkoney65 jkoney65 at yahoo.com
Wed Aug 22 23:18:35 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 176069

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Ken Hutchinson" <klhutch at ...> 
wrote:
>
> Ken:
> 
> It has been discussed before and Sue is right, Ms. Rowling is wrong.
> Harry cannot go on to become a mad eye Moody if he means to end the
> power of the elder wand. It is way too big a risk. However, someone
> else pointed out that Harry could work for the auror office and even
> head it up without ever being a field agent.
> 
> 
 In DH Harry became a master of
> combining information to see through it to the motives and plans of
> his opponent. He became a master detective. It is a talent he has
> shown all along and it really blossomed in the final book.
> 
> That is a talent that the auror office can use and it can be done
> almost completely from a desk, safe inside the Ministry. It's not 
like
> Harry has anything left to prove about his personal courage. Of 
course
> our dear author is anything but a master at putting together
> information like this so I have no doubt that when she writes her
> encyclopedia of the Potterverse she will have Harry out there 
slinging
> lead at the bad guys like Eliot Ness on steriods.
> 
> And that is just wrong....
> 
> Personally I think it is wrong on a different level too. I don't 
think
> that Harry wants to be an auror anymore, he's done that to death. At
> the end Harry says he's had enough trouble for a lifetime. I believe
> him, I hope the author does too. Harry needs to do something else 
with
> his life and he has earned the right to a peaceful but rewarding
> existence. He's really been set up to become a champion for civil
> rights for the other magical creatures and Muggles, if you ask me.
> 
> Ken


Jack-A-Roe:
The only problem I have with the theory that he worked at a desk full 
time is that the ministry wouldn't let him do it. 

He's got a reputation that is bigger than anything else. The ministry 
is going to want to show that he's out in the field keeping the 
magical world safe. His reputation alone will stop a number of bad 
guys. It's the "oh shit" he killed Voldemort by himself. The actual 
facts will be lost. 

"When the legend becomes fact, print the legend" 

He will also have a bunch of wizards gunning for him. Kind of like an 
old gunslinger. Everyone wants to make their reputation by killing 
him. Staying at a desk will not prevent this from happening. 

Anyone who defeats him will still have to find the Elder wand. Only 
Ron & Hermione know what he's going to do with it. So I think it's 
rather safe even if he is out catching the bad guys.

Jack-A-Roe







More information about the HPforGrownups archive