Foreshadowing in PoA movie

[springhollowranch]

No: HPFGUIDX 176260

I don't usually post, but I know there was some discussion after the
last book was read about what JKR meant when she said there was a scene
in PoA that "gave her chills."  We have the dvd and my children have
watched it about a million times, and I have been re-reading the series
as a whole.  I wonder if it could be the part where Harry and Sirius
are talking and he says something like--it's a shame I got to spend so
much time with James and so very little time with you--can't remember
the direct quote, but then in HBP Dumbledore says to Harry "it's cruel
that you and Sirius had such a short time together."  I wonder if her
chills were because she knew that she would kill Sirius off in OoP.

springhollowranch


***Elfy reminder*** Discussion of JKR's comment and possible foreshadowing in the books needs to refer to canon.  Please take other discussion about movies to our sister list, HPFGU-Movie:

http://movies.groups.yahoo.com/group/HPFGU-Movie/