Death and portraits

Ersatz Harry ersatzharry at yahoo.com
Tue Aug 28 02:45:55 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 176329

As Snape's memories attest in DH, Dumbledore is still able to
comprehend and influence events that occurred after his death.  In
particular, I am thinking of his telling Snape to deliver the sword to
the Forest of Dean.  It seems odd to call someone dead when he can
still act in this way, and I don't recall any other portraits having
quite that sort of ability (or if they did, they never seem to have
used it).  Are there others that anyone recalls, and can we truly call
Dumbledore dead when he still has such a hand in the story?

Ersatz Harry, who notices that people don't often append these little
parenthetical comments to their signatures these days





More information about the HPforGrownups archive