What's good about the good guys?

[lesley]

No: HPFGUIDX 179585

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Carol" <justcarol67 at ...> wrote:
> We've heard a lot of complaints lately about the good guys,
> particularly Dumbledore. I'd like to turn that around and
> ask those who admire those characters and even those who
> are disappointed in them to consider what's good about the
> good guys

Lesley
I'd like to bring the MOM and Scrimgeour into this as despite
the many wrongs, Scrimgeour came good in the end as he was
tortured for Harry's whereabouts but he kept silent and was
killed. I think he was doomed to die anyway but he must have
had a genuine sense of good otherwise he would have given Harry
up to spare himself the torture.

I think the MOM in general were good and would have done a lot
to help from year 4 if they had had better leaders, after all
no-one would have wanted LV back unless they were DEs. I think
their actions should be put down to stupidity.

Lesley