[HPforGrownups] Re: RE polyjuice

k12listmomma k12listmomma at comcast.net
Thu Dec 13 18:20:57 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 179836

Laura:
> I wonder if Moody's PJ potion was actually brewed by Snape, since
> it was never clear that the real Moody was good a brewing potions.
> If so, the Half-Blood Prince could have made significant changes in
> the PJ potion.  After all, the book that Hermione got the recipe from
> was very old.  And the HBP was certainly an outstanding potion
> master.


Shelley:
I had wondered that too, if Snape had made it. But if the trio knew that 
Snape had brewed it, would they have trusted it? Certainly, they trusted 
Moody.

But what really bothered me about that potion was the time that it takes to 
brew it- and the fact that the "multiple Harry" plan was recently hatched, 
leading me to question at all where this large stockpile of PJ suddenly came 
from to have on hand to be used for this plan? What had Moody used it 
before, that he happened to have a large batch for them to just use? 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive