Why Harry did not kill Bella WAS: Re: horcruxes

dumbledore11214 dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Tue Dec 18 17:10:35 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 179946

CJ:
> Harry performed two of the three Unforgivables -- crucio'ing Carrow 
in the
> Gryffindor Commons, and tossing Imperios around Gringott's like 
Christmas
> candy -- and attempted the third against Snape at the end of book 
six. Harry
> was far from pure. 

Alla:

Sure, but he did not kill anyone and consciously tried not to - in my 
book that counts for something.

CJ:
Not even particularly admirable.

Alla:

That's your opinion. I do not need him to be pure to be admirable. In 
my 
opinion he tried to do right thing enough times to admire him for 
that. He failed a lot too of course.

JMO.

Alla.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive