Harry's scar and Quirrell-mort
whirledgirl
blink_883 at hotmail.com
Mon Feb 5 17:00:52 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 164630
Carol wrote:
> As you say, Harry's scar only hurt when Quirrell was facing
> *backwards* and Voldemort was looking at him through the back of
> Quirrell's head (as when Quirrell was talking to Snape at the
> breakfast table). It's coincidence, of course, that Snape was looking
> into Harry's eyes at that very moment. (Wonder what he saw there?)
>
> But Voldemort would have to be looking at Harry and thinking about
him with anger and hatred for Harry's scar to hurt. Possibly Voldemort
saw Harry's expression of pain that morning at breakfast, and
certainly he saw his hand go to his scar. He would be careful not to
cause any such reaction again and arouse suspicion against Quirrell.
....
Whirlegirl replies:
I think the clue is in the 'seeing'.
Some points that may help clarify;
1. Quirrel was talking to Snape, wearing a turban.
2. Voldemort is sharing Quirrel's head. I think we could assume that
Voldie could sense what Quirrel is thinking.
which brings me to point 3...
3. Maybe Voldemort was *actually* pissed off at Snape, as he knew
(well, at any rate he could HEAR) that Quirrel was talking to SS.
So, that means that at that point in time, due perhaps to their
proximity, Harry was able to pick up on Voldie's anger/hatred at being
in the presence of *Snape*. It is possible as Snape says in HBP (to
Bellatrix) that Voldemort *thought he was DD!M* - never mind whether
*we* think so or not.
Finally, Voldie does (if i'm not mistaken - i guess i should reread
PS!) ask Quirrel to take his turban off to see Harry. Apologies if
this last point is incorrect, but the rest still stands, and explains
how Quirrel could turn around in lessons and Harry not feel a thing.
WG*
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive