Thank You (Re: Dumbledore in book 7)

[colebiancardi]

No: HPFGUIDX 164914

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Ronin_47" <Ronin_47 at ...> wrote:
 <snip>
> I do remember scenes where Harry hears whispered voices from outside the
> Headmaster's door. But that isn't really evidence that they were having
> intellectual discussion. We know that many of the portraits of previous
> heads are also housed in other locations, including 12 Grimmauld
Place, St.
> Mungos and the MoM. These voices Harry heard could have been nothing
more
> than the portraits giving Dumbledore their reports from their other
> locations.  
<snip>

colebiancardi here:
one thing I DO remember from HBP is how alert & interested the
portraits were when Harry & DD talked about the Horcruxes - the scene
right after they view Slughorn's unaltered memory.

whether or not the portraits can have "intellectual discussions" (and
I think they can...), they do have a lot of knowledge and they do know
about the Horcruxes.  And that is important.

colebiancardi