Bathroom scene again WAS: Re:Weasley Family Dynamics

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 164965

> Alla wrote:
> <snip>
> > I am still absolutely convinced that the **only** reason Snape 
does 
> > not talk about Sectusemptra much is because he is afraid that 
Draco 
> > is going to end up in Azkaban.
> > 
> > And Snape did not punish Harry? Detentions are punishment, are 
they 
> > not?
> 
> Carol responds:
> But how could Draco end up in Azkaban for a spell that he didn't
> complete? It wouldn't even show up on his wand. And Harry has also
> attempted to cast Crucio twice, once interrupted like Draco's, once
> completed but unsuccessful because he didn't "mean" it (didn't have
> sufficient sadism to sustain it). So should Harry be in Azkaban, 
too?
<BIG SNIP>

Alla:

I actually did not say that Draco should be in Azkaban, I only said 
that Snape was afraid that he **would be**, so to answer the modified 
question - yes, I think that if somebody else knew about Harry's 
casting curses like that, he would have a big chance to end up in 
Azkaban, whether he meant it or not.

Should he be there? No, not IMO. Not unless he truly meant it. Harry 
of course.

And how they would have learned? I don't know - legilimency, 
veritaserum, take your choice.

JMO,

Alla