[HPforGrownups] Re: Underage wizards

Vexingconfection at aol.com Vexingconfection at aol.com
Sat Feb 17 13:41:45 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 165103

 
In a message dated 2/17/2007 8:04:54 AM Eastern Standard Time,  
bboyminn at yahoo.com writes:

>That  brings up the question whether the Minstry can
>distinguish between underage  magic and adult magic.
>It is not clear, but I think the /most/ evidence  
>indicates that they can not. 


OK-I am new at this-but eager to learn! Having just discover HP books I am  
in awe of them and those that know them as extensively as this group seems to.  
That being said, Mundungus disaparated in front of the Dursleys right before 
the  dementor incident, the bang that Harry and the other residents of Privet  
Drive heard. Since no one came then-wouldn't that be due to adult magic?  And 
the flying car was also magic although it was bewitched by Mr. Weasley and  
not his children there was still magic in that area-right? But then the MoM  
didn't send an owl when Dobby aparated or disaparated from the home-only the  
hover charm.... Someone stop me I am getting headache...so is aparating  and 
disaparating not considered part of the ministry's target  watch? The "Hover 
Charm" was a charm so is there a difference maybe  between charms, spells, 
bewitchments, etc.? And what about all those  things Harry did before he knew he was 
a wizard? His hair grew back from  bad hair cuts, he found himself on top of a 
building, set a snake free, things  like that? 
Thank you all for you tremendous insight-it's been very helpful.
Vexies


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]





More information about the HPforGrownups archive