Bathroom Scene - A Different Perspective

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 165130

> Magpie:
<SNIP>
> Hey, I'm "okay with it" too. I'm not horrified by Harry in the 
scene. I 
> liked Draco being sliced up (we Draco fans often love our 
hurt/comfort). 
> And I don't have to pretend Harry was afraid of being insane to be 
okay with 
> it either, which I don't think he was at all.

Alla:

Pretend? I would say that assumption that Harry was horrified that 
he would become insane after knowing what he was tortured at 
Graveyard and what happened to Longbottoms has more canon support 
that he was not.

 
Magpie: 
<SNIP>
> Maybe I want to analyze that a bit beyond "Harry's a great kid so 
of course 
> he feels badly at hurting someone...even if he was totally 
justified and it 
> was all Malfoy's fault and the detentions are totally unfair!"
> 

Alla:

That is your right, but if your analysis reaches a conclusion that 
Harry had an intent to hurt Draco beyond defending himself against 
enemy, some people (me) would continue to disagree with that and I 
do not think I should not do so as well.

JMO,

Alla