Snape and Dumbledore on the Tower: A Defense of Snape

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 165277

> > Eggplant
> >
> > And I don't quite get your point about Avada Kedavra; I don't much
> > care if Snape killed him with it or in some other way, the point is 
he
> > killed him.
> >
> 
> Kemper now:
> We won't know until 7/21 whether or not Snape killed Dumbledore.

Alla:

Sorry, Kemper, but I am jumping in for a second just to disagree with 
your wording. IMO we **do** know that Snape killed Dumbledore, because 
he said AK and Dumbledore died.

I know, I know it is a straightforward reading, but I  just think that 
is too much of switching the gears, so to speak

It is the same for me as if you would say that we don't know whether 
Lupin is Evil or not.

As far as I am concerned we do know that he is not evil. Now, there is 
a possibility that he IS, since clues can be interpreted Pippin's way, 
but from reading the text I do not see that he is.

Same with Snape's killing Dumbledore. It is of course possible that 
Avada Kedavra is not really AK and poison did  Dumbledore in, but that 
is not what I read on the page.

It is IMO reading between the words and it is of course can be correct, 
if that makes sense. 

Kemper:
> It could have been the poison from the cave that did Dumbledore in.

Alla:

Yes, sure it could have been.

Kemper:
> And it was neverbadandneverwrongHarry that forced that down 
Dumbledore's throat.

Alla:

LOL.