[HPforGrownups] Re: Harry's "friend," the HBP (Was: Freud and JKR / Id vs...

[Vexingconfection at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 165300

 
 
> >>Betsy Hp:
> > <snip> 
> > The Prince,  IMO, is all about animal need (or the id) at the point
> > he  invented that spell. This is a boy on his way to becoming a 
> >  Death Eater, after all.
> > <snip>

>  >>Carol:
> From my point ov view, Sectumsempra is about a boy on  his way to
> becoming a Death Eater. "For Enemies" more than suggests  that he has
> revenge on his mind. But Muffliato is just a charm to  allow a kid to
> talk with his friends without being overheard.
>  <snip>



Who thinks Harry is going to be evil as  well? Almost everything that happens 
to him is because of his own  disobedience. SS-he broke rules and went to a 
duel. CoS- he  kidnapped a teacher and forced him into the chamber.  PoA- he  
attacked another teacher and his aunt. Let's the man who murdered his parents  
go. GoF-cheated. OoP-He became the serpent, wanted to kill, disregarded orders 
 from Dumbledore, gets Sirius Black killed, etc. HBP-he knowingly cheats,  
deceives-whatever-forces Dumbledore to drink the water, etc. Through all of 
this  he threatens the Dursleys, sets a snake on his cousin, speaks parcel  
tongue.  What if the next book-Harry becomes another Dark Lord? Also  interesting 
is the fact that in the GOF-every prediction Harry makes comes  true-Harry has 
always been afraid he would fit in better at Slytherin.  Dumbledore tells him 
the only difference between he and Tom Riddle are the  choices they made. 
Harry's choices don't always seem to be the  best.
Again-living proof opinion does not equal  intelligence- please enlighten me.
Vexies