Snape and Dumbledore on the Tower/ Blood on DD face.

[Joshua Michael]

No: HPFGUIDX 165440

Draeconin wrote--
> Actually, no. There would have been broken bones, and the fall
> itself would have killed him if he weren't already dead, but the
> human body is pretty resilient. But the AK is supposed to be
> instantaneous. And the being 'flung back' by the AK? Nope. In every
> other case where the effects of the spell is shown, the victim
> simply slumps down, dead.  Sounds to me like JKR didn't care about
> the discrepancy, and was just going for dramatic effect.

> --Ronin's Comments--
> I believe Dumbledore was killed by the AK and that he was prepared
> to die.  But it's always a possibility I suppose that he survived.

Dear All,

This is an intro about me and my views on this. (You can read about musical me on my site.)  I am a huge HP fan - I watch the movies, have read the books too many times to remember and check Mugglenet everyday. (Got to love that site!)  Oh and read mugglenet fanfic!

Here are my 3 views:

1) Snape killed Dumbledore because Dumbledore asked him to.  This is why Snape was arguing with him in the forest.  He didn't want to kill him. My theory is this: Avada Kedavra needs hate - so Snape hated killing Dumbledore and he was able to perform the spell.  JK herself has confirmed in an interview that DUMBLEDORE IS DEAD 100%.  But recently she said he may make an appearance in Book 7 - maybe as a portrait.

2)Snape didn't kill Dumbledore - Because usually when Avada Kedavra is used the person just slumps down dead.  We never get to SEE Dumbledore's body at his funeral.

3) Dumbledore did die - but Fawkes' song brought him to life. This would explain why Madam Pomfrey's eyes were wide when she was in hospital - She's a healer and she realized Dumbledore's re-incarnation.  That's also why she didn't attend the funeral.

OH AND I BELIEVE SNAPE'S a good guy :)

Joshua
The RCMFluter
http://www.freewebs.com/rcmfluter
______________________P_____________________
()_( O )_____]_o_o_O_O_O_O_O_O_O_O_]d_O_O_O_)